Monday, April 28, 2008

In Defence of Patents - Tim Wilson, Times of India, 28th April, 2008

Intellectual Property (IP) has always been a niche public policy areaunderstood best by policy wonks and lawyers. Unless there is a majorcontroversy, IP tends to escape public consciousness. But that is changing.Over the past few years cam­paigns to undermine IP have increased and arenow reaching a fever pitch.

IP is essential because it provides the property rights needed for researchand development to attract investment with the prospect of a long-termdividend. Under­mining IP is equivalent to the traditional socialist ethos-divvy the spoils of today's research and development, rather than focusingon expanding it. And a lot is at stake-­according to the most recent figuresfrom the United Nations, the Indian patent registry receives more than90,000 applica­tions for patentable inven­tions each year. In spite of thissignificant contri­bution, there has been a global campaign to undermine IPrights by a group of anti-market activists, self-interested politicians,vested interests, and more recently, the infiltrated World HealthOrganisation (WHO).

Innovative medicines have been one of the big targets. These activists haveargued that IP rights increase the cost of medicines for the world's poor.Yet they ignore that one of the biggest contributors to increasing costs isactually government imposed taxes and tariffs that raise the price oflife-saving medicines. For instance, in India the combined taxes and tariffson imported medicines are 55 per cent; in China, they are 28 per cent.

But this reality has not stopped governments acting to undermine IP. Inearly 2007, the then Thai military government waived the patents of threepatented medicines through a process called "compulsory licensing".Compulsory licensing is an instrument recognised under the World TradeOrganisation's Trade­ Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights(TRIPS) Agreement, and grants governments the ability to licence theproduction of patented products "in the case of a national emergency orother circumstances of extreme urgency or in cases of public non-commercialuse".

Now the WHO has waded into the debate. Last year, a WHO-designated teamassessed the Junta's actions and later issued a brief report legitimisingthe government's actions, which was followed by a how-to guide for countriesto waive their international obligations and issue compulsory licences.

This report is feeding into a WHO-initiated Intergovernmental Working Group(IGWG) on Public Health, Innovation and IP formed in 2006. From itsinception the IGWG has been an attempt for health bureaucrats and theactivists that advise them to rewrite - and undermine - global IP rules. The activists are now using their campaign against IP on medicines as aprecedent to continue their assault on IP; and global warming has become thenew battleground.

In a joint statement at the 2007 G8 summit, the governments of Brazil,China, India, Mexico and South Africa called for an agreement to assist incompulsory licensing the IP related to carbon dioxide emission-mitigatingtechnology being developed wealthy countries.

In subsequent media reports the officials argued an agreement is needed"paralleling the successful agreement on compulsory licensing ofpharmaceuticals". Similar themes appeared in a resolution passed by theEuropean Parliament in November last year recommending a study to assessamending TRIPS "to allow for the compulsory licensing of environmentallynecessary technologies".

And the tragedy is that those who are likely to suffer most are the world'spoor. Technology transfer is also vital for developing countries to growtheir economies and improve their standards of health and the environment. A 2006 World Bank study and a 1998 International Energy Agency /UNEP studyhave identified that strengthening IP rights assists in technology transfer.

The World Intellectual Property Organisation has designated 2008 as the yearfor "celebrating innovation and promoting respect for IP". With the IGWGconvening in Geneva in a few days' time and the assault on IP onclimate-friendly technologies, World IP Day - which was on Saturday -increasingly seems to be an occasion to reflect on IP's demise.

(The writer is director of the IP and Free Trade Unit at the Institute ofPublic Affairs in Melbourne.)


Isika Lisas said...

An invaluable resource and great addition to my favorites. The new features are well received on this end and will surely help the community share and progress more rapidly.
Quality treatment in India

Doccs Us said...

Our urgent care center, patients can be seen and treated, often in less than an hour, for injuries like minor lacerations, sprains, simple fractures, animal bites, sports injuries and other discomforts like sore throats, earaches, asthma attacks, migraines, urinary tract infections or the flu. Our urgent care facility is open seven days a week, 365 days a year including all holidays with convenient daytime and evening hours for patients seeking immediate treatment for minor illnesses and injuries as well as a wide variety of diagnostic and screening services including basic lab and x-rays.

anthem urgent care

Buydrug Seo said...

Very great post. I just stumbled upon your blog and wanted to mention that I’ve really enjoyed surfing around your blog posts. In any case I’ll be subscribing in your feed and I hope you write again very soon!
Buy Medicine in Mumbai

Patent search in India said...

Great post! There is some really helpful and interesting information here. Keep up the good work on this blog! Registered patent attorney India | Trademark search and registration|Patent valuation

Firoz Khan said...

NGO in Hyderabad India-OneLife (NGO) is a 24X7 Indian Suicide Hotline (+91-78930 78930) to address the suicidal tendencies, Teen Suicide Prevention & Depression Counseling. Contact us to help suicidal person

Social work for elderly said...

Make donation to support cancer care. You are able to surf the internet to explore a lot of charity in India sites that have their presence online.
You can pay cash to them through the online donation section of their website. So, make an online donation to the cause you feel you are more attached to including age care India and more.

Unknown said...

My name is jasvir singh i am from patiala,punjab . My father is cancer patient from last four years .we need financal help please contact me 9888370182 if anybody wants to help us.

jasvir singh said...

My name is jasvir singh i am from patiala,punjab . My father is cancer patient from last four years .we need financal help please contact me 9888370182 if anybody wants to help us.